wimlib

I update NTFS-3G to the latest "edge" branch and wimlib to version 1.10.0
When i apply windows 10 enterprise build 1607 64bit dutch i got this error message.

Applying image 1 ("Windows 10 Enterprise") from "/tftpboot/images/win10/image01/image.wim" to NTFS volume "/dev/sdb1"
[ERROR] Failed to set security descriptor on "/ProgramData/Microsoft/Settings/Accounts" in NTFS volume: Invalid argument
The security descriptor is: 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

This error occurred because libntfs-3g thinks the security descriptor is invalid. There are several known bugs with libntfs-3g's security descriptor validation logic in older versions. Please upgrade to NTFS-3G version 2016.2.22 or later if you haven't already.
ERROR: Exiting with error code 59:
Failed to set file owner, group, or other permissions on extracted file.

Is this another NTFS-3G bug?

Same issue for me, I downloaded the volume version of Windows 10, and I got this error with edge branch version. I use another Windows 10 iso (older) for the moment that work without any issue.

It's actually the same NTFS-3G bug, more or less. The earlier fix was incomplete.

I've written what I believe to be a correct fix and sent it to the NTFS-3G mailing list.

I've also attached the proposed patch to this post, so you can try it if you're interested.

synchronicity wrote:It's actually the same NTFS-3G bug, more or less. The earlier fix was incomplete.

I've written what I believe to be a correct fix and sent it to the NTFS-3G mailing list.

I've also attached the proposed patch to this post, so you can try it if you're interested.

Thanks for the patch.
It fixed the problemen.

The patch just goes perfect, thanks !!

I've uploaded a package ready (Debian Jessie) on my repository:
http://open.iabsis.com/

Regards,

Olivier.

synchronicity wrote:It's actually the same NTFS-3G bug, more or less. The earlier fix was incomplete.

I've written what I believe to be a correct fix and sent it to the NTFS-3G mailing list.

I've also attached the proposed patch to this post, so you can try it if you're interested.

I've just tried ntfs-3g 2017.3.23 and it still doesn't works. I've checked and your patch hasn't gone to this version. ntfs-3g 2017.3.23 with patch applied works perfect. I just want to make sure that folks from ntfs-3g didn't forget about your patch.

Thank you for your work.

I've packaged ntfs-3g with your patch for archlinux. It can be found here: https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/ntfs ... b-patched/

Sorry, what happened was that the NTFS-3G maintainer preferred something different, and I've been too lazy to make a new proposal. I'll look into it again.

Update: this was fixed by NTFS-3G commit 67feb2c286a3 ("Relaxed limitations on security descriptors"). You can find the development version of NTFS-3G at git://git.code.sf.net/p/ntfs-3g/ntfs-3g, branch "edge".

From my point of view, the problem has not been solved or is back! I tried to expand a 2016 WIM server. New ntfs-3g tools (2017.3.23) and new Wimlib. The switch "wimlib-imagex --no-acls" helps. Then the company expands and everything works. Unfortunately, every Windows directory has the permission "Everyone". Anybody got an idea?

sudo wimlib-imagex apply /var/tmp/install.wim 2 /dev/sdb1

Applying image 2 ("Windows Server 2016 SERVERSTANDARD") from "/var/tmp/install.wim" to NTFS volume "/dev/sdb1"
[ERROR] Failed to set security descriptor on "/ProgramData/Microsoft/Settings/Accounts" in NTFS volume: Invalid argument
The security descriptor is: 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

This error occurred because libntfs-3g thinks the security descriptor is invalid. There are several known bugs with libntfs-3g's security descriptor validation logic in older versions. Please upgrade to NTFS-3G version 2016.2.22 or later if you haven't already.
ERROR: Exiting with error code 59:
Failed to set file owner, group, or other permissions on extracted file.

ntfs-3g --version
ntfs-3g 2017.3.23 integrated FUSE 27